Skip to content 
When an Amazon seller has exhausted the platform’s appeals process, sent a formal letter of claim and still cannot resolve the problem, the next question is often whether litigation is worth pursuing.
In this follow-up episode of the Lawdit Podcast, Michael Coyle looks at what happens once pre-action correspondence has failed and a seller is considering taking the dispute further.
The discussion covers account deactivation, retained funds, court tracks, damages, settlement and the potential cost risks that come with litigation.
Start with pre-action
Before issuing proceedings, sellers should usually have gone through the pre-action stage.
Michael explains that by the time a client approaches Lawdit, they may already have exhausted Amazon’s internal appeals and support processes without resolving the issue. At that point, a formal letter of claim can be an important next step.
If that letter is ignored or the response is unsatisfactory, the decision then becomes relatively straightforward. The seller either moves on or considers issuing a claim.
Account deactivation and retained funds
Two of the most common issues discussed in the podcast are seller account deactivation and Amazon retaining money belonging to the seller.
Michael draws an important distinction between recovering retained money and claiming damages.
If Amazon is holding £20,000 belonging to a seller, recovering that £20,000 is one part of the dispute. But if the seller has also been unable to trade because the account was deactivated, the resulting business losses could potentially form a separate damages element within the same claim.
That distinction can be important when assessing the overall value of a dispute.
Which court track applies?
Civil litigation in England and Wales is divided into different tracks, including the small claims track, fast track, intermediate track and multi-track.
The value and complexity of the claim will usually influence where the case is allocated.
The podcast suggests that where the amount being retained is below £10,000, the claim may remain on the small claims track, although the court can consider whether the complexity of the dispute requires a different approach.
Claims above £10,000, particularly those involving substantial additional losses, may be allocated to a higher track.
Litigation can still lead to settlement
Issuing a claim does not necessarily mean the case will end up at trial.
Michael explains that Amazon may refer the matter to external solicitors, which can create an opportunity for meaningful negotiation and possible settlement.
However, sellers need to understand that settlement usually involves compromise. You may not get every outcome you originally wanted.
For example, a seller may want to be reinstated onto the Amazon platform, but the courts may be reluctant to become heavily involved in dictating who should or should not be allowed to trade on a private marketplace.
Mediation and cost risk
One of the strongest messages in this episode is the importance of remaining open to settlement and mediation.
Michael advises sellers to consider reasonable proposals to pause proceedings, mediate or otherwise seek a negotiated resolution.
That is particularly important because the general principle in English litigation is that the losing party can be ordered to pay the successful party’s legal costs. Michael warns that defending a substantial case could generate very significant legal fees.
Litigation should therefore never be approached casually.
Make sure your own position is in order
Before taking action against Amazon, sellers also need to make sure there is not a valid reason for the account restriction.
The podcast highlights potential issues involving intellectual property, parallel imports, VAT, changes to company information and Know Your Customer requirements.
Where the underlying problem can be rectified, sellers should consider addressing that first before escalating the dispute.
Act promptly
The final point is timing.
Limitation periods can apply, documents need to be organised and sellers should avoid leaving unresolved disputes sitting indefinitely.
If your Amazon seller account has been deactivated, your funds are being withheld or you have reached the end of Amazon’s internal appeals process, Lawdit may be able to advise on the options available.
Visit Lawdit.co.uk to find out more.
This article is for general information only and does not constitute legal advice.
